South Carolina AG Demands Death Penalty in Logan Federico Murder; Solicitor Responds
South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson on Sept. 30 urged Fifth Circuit Solicitor Byron Gipson to seek the death penalty against Alexander Devonte Dickey in the fatal shooting of 22‑year‑old college student Logan Federico, giving Gipson until Oct. 10 to declare his intentions and warning the AG’s office is prepared to assume the prosecution if Gipson does not proceed. Gipson replied Oct. 1 calling the deadline “reckless, irresponsible and unethical,” saying forensic testing remains pending, many prior arrests occurred outside his jurisdiction and the defendant’s rap sheet was incomplete, while prosecutors and family members have said Dickey had numerous prior charges and allegedly used the victim’s debit card after the killing.
Media
Crime
State & Local
Politics
Public Safety
Transportation
Legal
🔍 Key Facts
- On Sept. 30 South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson sent a letter urging Fifth Circuit Solicitor Byron Gipson to seek the death penalty against Alexander Devonte Dickey in the killing of 22‑year‑old Logan Federico, giving Gipson until Oct. 10 to declare his intentions and warning the AG’s office is prepared to take over the prosecution if Gipson 'is unable to proceed.'
- Solicitor Byron Gipson responded Oct. 1, calling Wilson’s deadline 'reckless, irresponsible and unethical,' and stating that key forensic testing remains pending and that many of Dickey’s prior arrests occurred outside Gipson’s jurisdiction.
- Alexander Dickey is accused of fatally shooting Logan Federico in Columbia; authorities say he was arrested the day after the killing and allegedly used Federico’s debit card at a store following the murder.
- Reporting indicates Dickey had an extensive criminal history — sources cite roughly 39 prior charges and earlier arrests for first‑degree burglary — but in 2023 he pleaded to a reduced charge as a 'first‑time offender,' and the solicitor’s office said a rap sheet was incomplete because his fingerprints had not been properly recorded.
- The case has fueled public outrage and partisan debate over pretrial release and 'soft‑on‑crime' policies; Federico’s father testified at a U.S. House field hearing in Charlotte, and lawmakers have proposed reforms (including North Carolina Republicans’ 'Iryna’s Law' package) aimed at tightening pretrial release and supervision.
- Wilson’s demand for capital punishment and his offer to assume the prosecution occur amid a broader pattern of heightened prosecutorial and federal interest in high‑profile violent cases (for example, DOJ involvement and potential death‑penalty actions in the Charlotte light‑rail killing), underscoring escalating political pressure on local prosecutors.
📊 Analysis & Commentary (2)
Progressive cities face billions in economic losses as retail crime surges 93% since 2019
"The op‑ed argues that progressive ‘soft‑on‑crime’ policies—illustrated by the Charlotte killing of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska—are driving a surge in retail theft and broader economic harm to major U.S. cities."
Good cities can't exist without public order
"The piece argues that cities only thrive with consistent public order and urges practical, data‑driven transit safety and enforcement over politicized calls for harsher punishments."
📰 Sources (11)
South Carolina AG demands death penalty against career criminal charged in college student’s murder
New information:
- South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson sent a Sept. 30 letter urging Fifth Circuit Solicitor Byron Gipson to seek the death penalty against Alexander Devonte Dickey.
- Wilson gave Solicitor Gipson until Oct. 10 to declare his intentions and warned the AG's office is prepared to take over the prosecution if Gipson 'is unable to proceed.'
- Solicitor Byron Gipson responded on Oct. 1 calling Wilson's deadline 'reckless, irresponsible and unethical,' noting forensic evidence remains pending and many prior arrests occurred outside his jurisdiction.
Charlotte train stabbing 911 audio released of deadly attack on Iryna Zarutska
New information:
- Charlotte‑Mecklenburg Police Department released audio of seven 911 calls from the immediate aftermath of the stabbing.
- Direct quotes from callers in the released 911 audio (e.g., 'This man f------ stabbed her for no reason'; 'This lady just got stabbed… there’s a lady on the ground, she’s bleeding a lot').
- Confirmation in this report that Decarlos Brown, 34, was arrested shortly after the incident and charged with first‑degree murder; police say he and Zarutska did not know one another.
- Timing detail: police say the stabbing occurred around 10:30 p.m. and Zarutska died at the scene.
Grieving dad torches lawmakers for soft crime policies that freed repeat offender who murdered his daughter
New information:
- Identification and details of a separate victim: 22-year-old Logan Federico was shot and killed in Columbia, South Carolina; her father Stephen Federico testified at the Charlotte hearing.
- Suspect named: Alexander Dickey is identified as Logan Federico's suspected killer; article reports he had 39 charges on his record before the murder.
- Prosecutorial/record detail: The solicitor's office later said a rap sheet was incomplete because Dickey's fingerprints were not properly recorded; Dickey had prior first-degree burglary arrests and pleaded to a reduced charge in 2023 as a 'first-time offender.'
- Behavior after the crime: Federico says Dickey used his daughter's debit card and other stolen cards at a store after the killing and was arrested the following day.
Grieving dad slams lawmakers for crime policies that freed daughter's suspected career criminal killer
New information:
- Reports that Alexander Dickey pleaded guilty in 2023 to a reduced charge as a first-time offender despite earlier arrests for first-degree burglary (which carries a 15-year minimum)
- Detail that Dickey allegedly used the victim's debit card at a store after the killing and was arrested the following day
- Direct on-the-record quote from Stephen Federico: 'I will fight until my last breath for my daughter' (family testimony at the Charlotte hearing)
US House members hear pleas for tougher justice policies after stabbing death of refugee
New information:
- A U.S. House judiciary subcommittee convened a field hearing in Charlotte on Sept. 29 to hear victims' families and local officials about the Aug. 22 killing of Iryna Zarutska.
- Testimony from Dena King, former U.S. attorney, that Mecklenburg County needs 'dozens' of additional prosecutors to cover a population of 1.2 million.
- A crime statistician testified that murder and violent-crime rates are falling nationwide and in Charlotte after earlier increases in the 2020s.
- Report that a magistrate released Decarlos Brown Jr. in January on a written promise to appear (misdemeanor release without bond), a procedural detail highlighted during the hearing.
- Description of sharp partisan exchanges at the hearing, including GOP Rep. Ralph Norman displaying a screenshot from surveillance video and Democrats calling the session political theater.
Charlotte light-rail stabbing murder spurs landmark criminal justice reform from North Carolina Republicans
New information:
- N.C. Republican leaders unveiled an "Iryna’s Law" package to tighten pretrial release, eliminate cashless bail, and increase accountability for magistrates and judges.
- The plan would allow GPS monitoring and conditional bond for a new category of violent offenses, and emphasize electronic monitoring and house arrest for certain repeat offenders.
- Death‑penalty appeals would be required to be adjudicated within two years of filing; leaders also said they are taking steps to revive the death penalty.
- Magistrates/judges who violate the new policies could face suspension or removal upon recommendation by a chief judge or Chief Justice Paul Newby.
Felon indicted in train murder as attacks terrorize commuters in blue city: report
New information:
- A Mecklenburg County grand jury returned a true bill indicting Decarlos Dejuan Brown Jr. on first-degree murder in the Aug. 22 light-rail killing of Iryna Zarutska.
- Brown’s next Superior Court hearing is scheduled for Oct. 16; if convicted, he faces life in prison or potentially the death penalty if sought by prosecutors.
- A judge ordered Brown to undergo a 60-day mental health evaluation at a regional hospital after finding his capacity to proceed is in question.
- Police say surveillance video captured the attack; the indictment lists numerous CMPD officers as witnesses.
- Article details additional recent incidents on or near Charlotte’s light rail (Aug. 24 biting, Aug. 30 assault with an arrest, Sept. 3 armed robbery).
Congress to hold crime hearing in Charlotte following deadly light rail attack
New information:
- House Judiciary Committee will hold a field hearing in Charlotte on Sept. 29 focused on crime and the recent light rail killing.
- The Department of Justice has charged suspect Decarlos Dejuan Brown Jr. in federal court.
- The Judiciary Subcommittee on Oversight will lead the hearing, and all committee members may attend.
- New on‑record statements from AG Pam Bondi and Rep. Jeff Van Drew tied to the case and policy debate.
Iryna Zarutska killing exposes GOP split on possible federal intervention in Charlotte
New information:
- U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi says DOJ may seek the federal death penalty and has directed prosecutors to federally prosecute suspect Decarlos Brown Jr.
- Sen. Thom Tillis (R‑N.C.) opposes federal intervention in Charlotte, calling it an overreach and saying other cities should be prioritized.
- Sen. Ted Budd (R‑N.C.) signals openness to federal/National Guard involvement, arguing local 'negligence' invites greater federal role.
White House torches media after killer’s mother admits son should’ve been jailed before Zarutska murder
New information:
- White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt publicly criticized the Washington Post’s coverage of the Iryna Zarutska killing in an X post, accusing it of downplaying the need to detain violent offenders.
- White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson told the Washington Post that 'violent criminals belong behind bars, not sitting behind innocent bystanders on public transportation.'
- White House spokeswoman Taylor Rogers told Fox News Digital the administration believes 'soft-on-crime policies' fuel violence and accused 'left-wing media' of defending career criminals.
- The suspect’s mother told local TV (WSOC-TV) she believed her son should have been detained at the time of the killing due to prior arrests and mental health concerns.
- The article reiterates Decarlos Brown Jr.’s record: 14 arrests over the last decade, convictions for larceny and breaking and entering (2013) and robbery with a dangerous weapon (2015, six-year sentence), with more recent charges for communicating threats and misuse of 911; he was not under state supervision at the time of the killing.
- The Washington Post article at issue was titled, 'Trump blames Democrats for Charlotte stabbing. Records complicate the story,' and cited experts calling permanent confinement for mentally ill people over minor offenses 'draconian.'
- White House officials (Leavitt, Jackson, Rogers) issued public and on-record statements condemning media framing and advocating detention of violent offenders.
- Suspect’s mother publicly said her son should have been detained given prior arrests and mental health issues.
Charlotte mayor sidesteps Trump’s death penalty demand in stabbing case
New information:
- Lyles declined to comment on Trump’s death penalty demand, focusing on transit safety and an FTA review.
- CATS will deploy new security teams and add about 30 security personnel on the Blue Line.
- Suspect Decarlos Brown Jr. allegedly made incriminating statements to his sister after the stabbing.
- North Carolina has a death penalty moratorium in practice since 2006.